Searching for "Finger Rockets" came back with lots of hits! Thanks guys.
http://search.ebay.c...QfkrZ1QQfromZR8
The only thing is that the one we had looks like it was probably more sturdy than those - it was two pieces (the yellow and black parts) and looked like it might have been a more dense foam. Plus, I'm guessing it had to be some kind of bigger name brand to have been at TRU... Either way - we can at least get these ones, and they're cheap.
Thanks again.
Kneel Before Zod's Content
There have been 3 items by Kneel Before Zod (Search limited from 12-November 96)